Some Topics to Consider When Critiquing Talks

Overall

In general, was the talk Excellent? Very Good? Good? Fair? Poor?

Content

• Central message is compelling (precisely stated, appropriately repeated, memorable, and strongly supported.)
• Good science
• Clear explanations
• Appropriate selection of information
• Appropriate amount of material for the length of the talk
• Slow beginning with sufficient background and definitions to understand the talk

Organization

• Logical flow
• Clear
• 3-part framework (“Tell them what you’re going to say; say it; tell them what you said”)
• Outline (given, followed)
• Parallel form used as needed

Visuals (Slides)

• Visible
• Simple
• Emphasis on important information
• Selection
• Number (not too many)
• Variety

Speaking Style (Language and Delivery)

• Audience contact and awareness
• Eye contact
• Attitude (friendly, calm, enthusiastic, …)
• Emphasis on important information
• Knowledgeable
• Answered questions well
• Use of pointer (not circling)
• Voice (loud, soft, monotonous)
• Accent, enunciation
• Pace
• Talking (not memorizing)
• Well-prepared
• Well-practiced